← Expectations

The “Everything” Strategy and The Story It Doesn’t Tell

When I was a young lass, I was very brave. One of my favorite mantras is, “I don’t know everything, but I know I can figure everything out.” When I was young, this made me very confident. Perhaps too confident.

A colleague or a client would ask, “So what would you do?” and I’d say, “Everything.” I’d answer with my whole heart, a twinkle in my eye and an open mind. Here’s the landscape. Here’s everything we could do. Here’s the challenge, and here’s some hope.

My strategy narratives were very Tolkien: the begats and the begots, so many layers of people and possibilities. Opportunities disguised as direction.

The room loved it. I was good at first impressions. Then, over time, the dissatisfaction would show up from project management, from account managers, from the client.

The strategy wasn’t bad. But in sharing it, I’d gotten everyone so lost in the world-building that they didn’t know where they were in the story.

I call this the Everything narrative. It works well in some situations, but it can burn you out and make your clients lose faith.

When “Everything.” worked

One of my first real career wins was a CPG launch. The campaign already existed, and the brand was heavily invested in content with social influencers. We were asked to get scrappy: how do we get their followers engaged enough to like the brand and buy it in grocery stores?

“What would you do?” had a narrow answer there, even if the answer was “Everything.”

Let’s run ads and promote the video launch as an event. Let’s get the influencers to chat with fans on our channels. Let’s engage them as the brand in-thread.

The influencers committed to content distribution up front. We ran Ask Me Anything-style Q&As on our social profiles, with the influencer taking questions live in the thread for an hour. I was the community manager, working the comments before and after. The community warmed up, the content reached more people, and the campaign won some local awards.

Same question, same me, same big-hearted answer, and it worked because we weren’t starting at “Chapter 1: In the beginning…”

The answer to “What would you do?” could be expansive because I wasn’t having to expand into unending directions. The structure of the engagement gave me the freedom to go hog wild without disappointing anyone.

When it didn’t

I worked on a lot of client projects where the ask was to “do social media.”

“What would you do?” came with an enormous answer: audit every channel, study the audience, define “good” and see what’s working, find every point of engagement, identify every resource making content, and pull it all into one clean content calendar.

Folks would ask for everything, but once they understood what it took to do that, nobody really wanted it.

Every team and client business unit had its own work and its own metrics, and none of them could see what my work did for them. To them it looked like someone at the center trying to take over. I was young, I hadn’t earned trust, and I couldn’t get anyone behind a single strategy.

I was trying to take the room on a journey where they were the good guys trying to do the right thing against all odds while evil forces were at work against them, but the journey became irrelevant because no one could figure out how they fit into it as an individual.

Even with unlimited budget and patient clients, I’ve learned that this is not the story to tell a room of decision makers.

What I got wrong

The story is just what happened. But narrative is the way that the story is told: what you focus on, how you flow across time within the story, and who is telling the story.

It was the way I was telling the story that was hurting my success. I told it as if everything was on the table right away, when the client had a bucket of money and a short list of things we could actually do.

I didn’t have the vocabulary to say up front what could go wrong for these people, what I’d need from them, and what “done” would look like.

What I do now

I’m more Douglas Adams these days. I skip the whole landscape and focus on one small corner of it: here’s the thing I looked at, here’s the quirk or surprise, here’s the real tragedy of it that we should’ve seen coming, or here’s how we move to the next thing, hopefully.

I try to keep nods to the past brief, relevant, and acknowledging of the work that went into making things the way they are today, even if it’s messy.

And then, crack on!

I try to tell shorter stories that connect to a bigger picture over time (if you’re paying attention), and hope that everyone in the room can find their piece of it. The client sees things getting made, the account manager has something to report, and the project manager can task it out.

I wish I’d gotten there sooner.

More from the blog